Loading chat...

CA SB467

Bill

Status

Passed

9/30/2022

Primary Sponsor

Scott Wiener

Click for details

Origin

Senate

2021-2022 Session

AI Summary

  • Allows prisoners to petition for habeas corpus relief when a significant dispute has emerged in the scientific community regarding expert medical, scientific, or forensic testimony used at trial, if the dispute would have likely changed the trial outcome.

  • Expands the definition of "false evidence" to include expert opinions undermined by the state of scientific knowledge or later scientific research and technological advances.

  • Permits courts to consider consensus or lack of consensus in the relevant scientific community when assessing whether a significant dispute about expert testimony is substantial enough to warrant relief.

  • Establishes that significant disputes can be demonstrated through credible expert testimony, declarations, or peer-reviewed literature showing that substantial numbers of experts have concluded developments undermine the reliability of the original expert's testimony.

  • Does not create additional liability for experts who repudiate their original opinions or whose opinions are undermined by scientific developments or reasonable disputes within their scientific community.

Legislative Description

Expert witnesses: writ of habeas corpus.

Last Action

Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 982, Statutes of 2022.

9/30/2022

Committee Referrals

Appropriations6/1/2022
Public Safety5/5/2022
Appropriations1/12/2022
Public Safety1/3/2022
Rules1/3/2022
Natural Resources and Water2/25/2021
Rules2/16/2021

Full Bill Text

No bill text available