Loading chat...

HI SB2810

Bill

Status

Introduced

1/23/2020

Primary Sponsor

Karl Rhoads

Click for details

Origin

Senate

2020 Regular Session

AI Summary

SB2810 Summary

  • Restricts declaratory judgments to cases where no legally cognizable injury has occurred and consequential relief could not currently be claimed, reversing the broader interpretation established by Act 74 of 1945.

  • Prohibits declaratory relief in district courts, tax controversies, cases involving constitutional provisions, divorce or annulment cases, cases with special statutory remedies, and cases where another cause of action exists.

  • Requires plaintiffs seeking declaratory relief to establish standing by proving: (1) actual or threatened injury to a legally protected interest, (2) injury fairly traceable to defendant's actions, and (3) favorable decision would likely provide relief.

  • Mandates that plaintiffs demonstrate a distinct and palpable injury rather than a generally available grievance affecting the public at large, excluding abstract, conjectural, or hypothetical harms.

  • Amends HRS §632-6 to bar parties from using declaratory judgment remedy once one party invades the rights asserted by the other, requiring them to pursue ordinary legal action instead.

Legislative Description

Relating To Declaratory Judgments.

Courts

Last Action

The committee on JDC deferred the measure.

2/20/2020

Committee Referrals

Judiciary1/27/2020

Full Bill Text

No bill text available