Loading chat...

HI HB174

Bill

Status

Introduced

1/22/2021

Primary Sponsor

Scott Saiki

Click for details

Origin

House of Representatives

2021 Regular Session

AI Summary

HB174 Summary

  • Adds new section 801K- establishing that noncompliance with eyewitness identification requirements or suggestive procedures alone does not require exclusion of evidence; admissibility depends on whether identification has sufficient reliability under totality of circumstances.

  • Removes requirement that law enforcement record eyewitness descriptions prior to photo or live lineups, and allows fillers to resemble suspect's appearance at time of offense without requiring contemporary photographs.

  • Modifies showup procedures to permit photo showups when suspect is already familiar to eyewitness (spouse, relative, co-worker, neighbor) and clarifies "exigent circumstances" as temporary detention/arrest at or near crime scene pending identity verification.

  • Changes suspect positioning in multi-eyewitness lineups from random placement to allowing suspect to select their own position for each eyewitness.

  • Simplifies recording requirements for identification procedures from requiring video record with audio and written alternatives to a single "record" requirement that includes identification results, personnel present, and relevant identifying information.

Legislative Description

Relating To Eyewitness Idenifications.

Honolulu Prosecuting Attorney Package

Last Action

The committee(s) on JHA recommend(s) that the measure be deferred.

3/2/2021

Committee Referrals

Judiciary & Hawaiian Affairs1/27/2021

Full Bill Text

No bill text available