Loading chat...
NY A09552
Bill
Status
1/14/2026
Primary Sponsor
Jo Simon
Click for details
AI Summary
-
Amends New York Civil Practice Law and Rules section 5501(c) to require appellate courts give "the highest degree of deference" to jury factual findings, including damage awards
-
Replaces the current "deviates materially from reasonable compensation" standard with a "shocks the conscience" standard for overturning jury verdicts
-
Requires the moving party to prove by "clear and convincing evidence" that a verdict is so extraordinary no reasonable jury could have reached it
-
Mandates appellate courts view evidence in the light most favorable to the prevailing party and prohibits substituting judicial judgment for jury determinations on credibility or damages
-
Applies to all actions filed on or after the bill's effective date
Legislative Description
Requires the appellate division gives the highest degree of deference to the jury's fact finding, including its assessment of damages.
Last Action
referred to judiciary
1/14/2026